DR JAMES LAMB
  • About
  • Publications
  • BLOG
  • About
  • Publications
  • BLOG

Positive feedback from Sian on my proposal

27/11/2012

0 Comments

 
Following a pleasant weekend in Berlin, I returned to some positive news yesterday evening. Sian has responded positively to my proposed research and has made some useful suggestions for the next step forward:
"Hi James

This is looking very good. I really like the way you've pulled this together. I have just a few points, and apologies that the ethics ones seem a bit nitpicky : / :

  • I think the second research question is a bit vague, though I see what you're getting at. I think you might tighten it a little to focus on how assessment criteria are defined for multimodal assignments, and how assessors approach the making of quality judgements of these artfacts - something like that?
  • On the ethics form, question 5.9 I don't think you need to indicate that the purpose of the research will be concealed: I'm not quite sure what you mean here, but this certainly isn't a piece of covert research, for which particular ethical rationales would need to be given. Just say 'no' to this one...
  • On question 6.1, you will need to get consent from interview participants (I can see why the rubric is misleading) - however generating original interview data does require consent. Just use the 'geographies' project one as a template (attached). We can discuss what kind of consent you might need for the observations - probably none so no need to mention that here.
  • In section 8.2 - you need to be clear that audio recording will be used (if that's your intention). In 8.3, say that all transcripts and extracts used will be anonymised, rather than that anonymity will be offered. Similarly in 8.4, just say that pseudonyms *will* be used rather than 'where appropriate' (ie for this kind of ethics application anonymity is always appropriate! well, almost always...)

That's pretty much it - if you could revise the ethics application (and the research question, if you agree!) and send it back, we can agree that's the final version.

Then we should meet to discuss getting all this set up - my diary is pretty packed between now and Christmas, I expect yours is too. But monday 10th in the morning? 9 or 10? Or the afternoon of friday 14th?

Great stuff - I think you've really got this underway now.

Sian"
I'll move on these actions right away, including responding to set up a meeting to get things underway. Good news for the time being, however.
0 Comments

Sian...and Fitzpatrick...on multimodality

25/11/2012

0 Comments

 
Just noticed this from Sian on Facebook. No time to reflect on it just now so will bookmark it in the form of a screenshot:
Picture
0 Comments

Deeper than the eye can see: seminar by Natasa Lackovic

20/11/2012

0 Comments

 
Picture
This evening I attended an interesting and useful session by Natasa Lackovic on the subject of visual research methodologies. Natasa had prepared a video presentation in advance of the session that I watched earlier today (and for which I have a few pages of hand written notes). Here's the link to the video:
And here are some of my notes from this evening's session (with a full transcript at the bottom).
Some texts mentioned during the seminar:
  • Carey Jewitt, Multimodality handbook
  • Mitchell, Doing visual research
  • Ways of seeing, didn't catch this one
  • Mirzoeff, Visual culture reader, 
  • Selfe and Selfe, Desktop metaphors
  • Derrida - maybe something about deconstruction?
deeper_than_the_eye_transcript.pdf
File Size: 62 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

0 Comments

Research proposal submitted

20/11/2012

0 Comments

 
As of Sunday past, my dissertation proposal and ethics form have been submitted. Sian is going to get back to me later this week with initial feedback and then to set up a supervisory meeting. Here are the documents:
jlamb_dissertation_ethics_form_19_nov_2012
File Size: 122 kb
File Type: jlamb dissertation ethics form 19 nov 2012
Download File

j_lamb_research_proposal_19_november
File Size: 101 kb
File Type: j lamb research proposal 19 november
Download File

0 Comments

Looking forward to visual literacy seminar

19/11/2012

0 Comments

 
The following information snet through from Jen Ross ahead of Natasa Lackovic's session on visual literacy next Tuesday. The video doesn't play (something to do with Windows Media Player, apparently) so I'll need to try go in early to work and try and catch it before Tuesday.
"Hello everyone,

I'm writing with details of the "deeper than the eye can see" event with our guest expert, Natasa Lackovic from the University of Nottingham. MSc in E-learning participants, alumni, teachers and friends are all welcome to join in next week on Tuesday 20 November, 7:30-8:30pm UK time.

Before the event, please watch Natasa's introduction and her video lecture. These are available at:

mms://resources.lsri.nottingham.ac.uk/stream/natasa/introduction.wmv
mms://resources.lsri.nottingham.ac.uk/stream/natasa/screencast.wmv
 
These streams will play in a number of clients across various platforms including Windows, Mac and Linux. The open source client VLC worked well for me, and this is a free download from: http://www.videolan.org/vlc/

Then, on the 20th, join us in Blackboard Collaborate for an hour-long discussion session at 7:30pm (UK time). Along with talking with Natasa about her research and presentation, and learning more about visual methods, this should be a great opportunity to get and share some inspiration and insights for your own research projects or assignments.

On the 20th, you can access the Collaborate session through the MSc E-learning Moodle course, or directly at this link:

https://sas.elluminate.com/m.jnlp?sid=2011426&password=M.745C01385F5224536FD3990C738F6B

If you haven't run Collaborate recently, you should check your setup - directions for this below.

If you have any questions, please let me know! 

Looking forward to seeing you online next Tuesday evening!

Jen


Check computer setup for Collaborate
1. Check your operating system and Java: Computer Configuration check

2. Use Configuration room v11 to test your connection, settings, and configure your audio.

More info is here: http://www.ed.ac.uk/schools-departments/information-services/services/learning-technology/communication/collaborate/preparing

If you require technical help, contact the University Helpline [email protected] (tel:  0131 651 5151) for technical support."
0 Comments

Thomas et al. (2007): Transliteracy: crossing divides

18/11/2012

0 Comments

 
Another potentially valuable paper from EDC 10. Direct citation indented, followed by my comments in turn.
"Transliteracy might provide a unifying perspective on what it means to be literate in the twenty-first century. It is not a new behavior but has only been identified as a working concept since the Internet generated news ways of thinking about human communication." 
Comment:
"We live in a world of multiple literacies, multiple media and multiple demands on our attention."

and

"In this article, we explore a new concept - "transliteracy' - which is both very old and brand new and may help us shed light on how we, as human beings, communicate."
Comment:
"Transliteracy is the ability to read, write and interact across a range of platforms, tools and media from signing and orality through handwriting, print, TV, radio and film, to digital social networks."
Comment:
"...the concept of transliteracy calls for a change of perspective away from the battles over print versus digital, and a move instead towards a unifying ecology not just of media, but of all literacies relevant to reading, writing, interaction and culture, both past and present."
Comment:
"Is the internet really changing the ways in which we read, write, and think? Is the book truly dead? Is anything being lost in the frantic rush to get online? What has happened to the idea of literary value?"
Comment:
"Many people seem to feel that they should have a preference between the analogue and the digital, as it the situation really were so polarized."
Comment:
"However, it is important to note that transliteracy is not just about computer-based materials, but about all communication types across time and culture. It does not privilege one above the other but treats all as of equal value and moves between and across them."
0 Comments

Julier (2006): From Visual Culture to Design Culture

16/11/2012

0 Comments

 
Not too much to draw from this secondary reading from the EDC10 course. Perhaps a few useful points to confirm ideas in other articles.
Citing Scott Lash:

"Culture is now three-dimensional, as much tactile as visual, all around us and inhabited, live in rather than encountered in a separate realm as a representation."

and:

"Culture is no longer one of pure representation or narrative, where visual culture conveys messages. Instead, culture formulates, formats, channels, circulates, contains and retrieves information."
"Furthermore, virtual reality becomes an, albeit extreme, metaphor for change in the rules of engagement between subject and object. 

and:

"The promise not so much convergent media, but rather, simultaneous and concurrent experiential moments."
"One is that design culture requires its observers to move beyond visual and material attributes to consider the multivarious and multilocational networks of its creation and manifestation."
0 Comments

Thomas et al. (2007): Transliteracy: Crossing divides

16/11/2012

0 Comments

 
Useful stuff on transliteracy (and some mentions of multimodality) in this reading from the EDC10 course:
"The ability to read, write, and interact across a range of platforms, tools and media from signing and orality through handwriting, print, TV, radio and film, to digital social networks." 
Comment:
"In this article, we explore a new concept - "transliteracy" - which is both very old and brand new"
Comment:
"the concept of transliteracy calls for a change of perspective away from the battles over print versus digital, and a move instead towards a unifying ecology not just of media, but of all literacies relevant to reading, writing, interaction and culture, both past and present."
Comment:
"Across this long stretch of cultural time, five million years of human communication, the privileging of reading and writing as primary defining literacies begins to seem somewhat out of scale."
Comment:
"But humans have only been using reading and writing for a very short time in our history, so how else do we communicate?" Transliteracy pays attention to the whole range of modes and the synergies between them to produce a 'transliterate lifeworld' in constant process."
Comment:
"It is an interstitial place teeming with diverse life-forms, some on the rise, some in decline, expressed in many languages in many voices, many kinds of scripts and media."
Comment:
"There are more similarities between modes than may be at first apparent, and the technological skills involved are often simple to acquire if the user is positively inclined to attempt them."
Comment:
"As we have seen, transliteracy involves being able to read, write and interact across multiple modes."
Comment:
"However, materials does not have to be digital to be multimodal."
Comment:
0 Comments

A possible exercise to include within my methodology

13/11/2012

0 Comments

 
Clara suggested inviting interview participants to bring a piece of multimodal assessment to the interview. I wonder instead whether I should present the participants with a piece of multimodal assessment and use it as a source of discussion? I quite like this idea.
0 Comments

Kress (2006): Gains and losses

13/11/2012

0 Comments

 
Once again, from one of my EDC10 binders of readings. Cited text from the paper indented, followed by my comments in each case.
"The current home page is profoundly different. It is not organized following the logic of the traditional written page but following that of the image-based logic of contemporary pages. Tellingly and more significantly, this page has thirteen distinct entry points where the 1992 page had one." (p9)

and

"It was an entry point given by convention and used by the author. Access to the power of authorship was strictly governed." (p9)
Comment:
"The existence of the different entry points speaks of a sense of insecurity about the visitors, a feeling or fragmentation of the audience - who are no longer just readers but visitors a quite different action being implied in the change of the name." (p9)
Comment:
"This then leaves the task of finding principles that will show the 'affordances', distinct potentials and limitations for representation of the various modes." (p12)
Comment:
"Sequence is used to make meaning; being first has the potential to mean something other than being second or being last." (p12)

and

"Sequence has effects for authorship and for reading." (p13)
Comment:
"Speech and writing tell the world; depiction shows the world. in the one, the order of the world is that given by the author; in the other, the order of the world is yet to be designed (fully and/or definitely) by the viewer." (p16)
Comment:
"The new constellation of image and screen - where screen, the contemporary canvas, is dominated by the logic of image..." (p18)
Comment:
"Where with traditional pages, in the former semiotic landscape, it was the power of the author that rules, here, it is the interest of the reader, derived from the contingencies and needs of their life-worlds." (p18)
Comment:
"The new media make it possible to use the mode that seems most apt for the purposes of representation and communication." (p19) 

and

"I can now choose the mode according to what I know or might imagine is the preferred mode of the audiences I have in mind." (p19)


Comment:
"That certainty is gone; each occasion of representation and communication now becomes one in which the issue of my relation to my audience has to be newly considered and settled on." (p19)
0 Comments
<<Previous

    Categories

    All
    Abandoned Ideas
    Abstract
    Acknowledge And Bib.
    Actions/things To Do
    Appendix
    Brian Eno
    Carey Jewitt
    Conclusion
    Constellation Map
    Data
    Data Emergent Ideas
    Digital Spaces
    Dissemination
    Dissemination Rationale
    Eca
    Ethics
    Fitzpatrick
    Glossary
    Hypertext Links
    Ideas
    Image
    Interviews
    Kress
    Land
    Literature/reading
    Lit Review
    Meetings
    Methodology
    Music
    Natasa Lackovic
    Observation
    Photography
    Research Proposal
    Sian
    Soundtrack
    Stephen Hunter
    Time Needed For M
    Title
    Uni Crest
    Vectors
    Video
    Visual

    Archives

    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012

    Timeline

    Picture
    Other stuff
    Resources page
    Moodle
    EDC13
[email protected]